Suggestions by @hybridmoments

Neil Sandilands

as The Major in The Long Walk

Score: +1

Kat Dennings

as Jane the Killer in Creepypasta (Live Action Movie)

Score: +1

Mads Mikkelsen

as Slender Man in Creepypasta (Live Action Movie)

Score: +2

Ross Lynch

as Raymond Garraty in The Long Walk

Score: +1

Dylan O'Brien

as Peter Mcvries in The Long Walk

Score: +1

Kaya Scodelario

as Jan in The Long Walk

Score: -1

Sam Strike

as Raymond Garraty in The Long Walk

Score: 0

Brad Pitt

as The Major in The Long Walk

Score: +2

Bruce Willis

as The Major in The Long Walk

Score: +2

Trevante Rhodes

as The Major in The Long Walk

Score: +1

Woody Harrelson

as The Major in The Long Walk

Score: +1

Denzel Washington

as The Major in The Long Walk

Score: +2

Charlie Plummer

as Stebbins in The Long Walk

Score: +1