Suggestions by @huffleben

Emma Stone

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: -1

Emily Browning

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: -1

Marissa Von Bleicken

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: -1

Flora Lis

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: +1

Maisie Stock

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: +1

Olivia Cooke

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: -1

Kaitlyn Dever

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: -1

Luca Hollestelle

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: +1

Hayley Williams

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: -1

Erin Kellyman

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: +1

Sofia Lillis

as Erin Delaney in Dalton

Score: 0

Leighton Meester

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -2

Alexa Nikolas

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1

Naya Rivera

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1

Rachel Bilson

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1

Adriana Lima

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1

Dylan Conrique

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1

Dua Lipa

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1

Katherine Langford

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1

Diana Silvers

as Tabitha Adams in Dalton

Score: -1