Suggestions by @hicpadoan

Ellian (Spellbound)

as 'Eliyyahu / אֱלִיָּהוּ (Elias / Elijah) in Characters by Name but I'm Excruciatingly Thorough

Score: +4

Ellian (Spellbound)

as E in Fictional Characters Face Claims Sorted by First Letter of First Name

Score: +5

Ellian (Spellbound)

as Rarely swears in Sorting Fictional Characters by how much they would swear.

Score: +2

Daisuke (Mouthwashing)

as Baby of the Bunch in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Dr. Delbert Doppler

as Babies Ever After in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Captain Amelia

as Babies Ever After in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Calypso (Epic: The Musical)

as Attempted Homewrecker in Sort by Tropes

Score: +3

Long John Silver

as Artificial Limbs in Sort by Tropes

Score: +3

Serena Blomstrand

as Arms Dealer in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Brian Murray

as John Silver in Treasure Planet 2

Score: +1

Williem Dafoe

as Ironbeard in Treasure Planet 2

Score: +1

Curly (Mouthwashing)

as An Arm and a Leg in Sort by Tropes

Score: +3

Long John Silver

as An Arm and a Leg in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Elphaba Thropp

as Appearance Angst in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Elisabeth Sparkle

as Appearance Angst in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Quasimodo

as Appearance Angst in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Ellian (Spellbound)

as Ambiguously Brown in Sort by Tropes

Score: +3

Serena Blomstrand

as Always Second Best in Sort by Tropes

Score: +1

Powder (Arcane)

as Alternative-Self Name-Change in Sort by Tropes

Score: +3

Powder (Arcane)

as Alternate Universe in Sort by Tropes

Score: +4