Suggestions by @heart16

Johnny Depp

as Charlie Thompson in The Drama 1986

Score: +1

Lisa Bonet

as Emma Harwood in The Drama 1986

Score: +1

David Eigenberg

as Kokava (Jake's lawyer) in Murder Between Friends

Score: +3

Leo Woodall

as Evan Miller in Murder Between Friends

Score: +2

FreeForm

as Streaming service in Murder Between Friends

Score: +1

Matthew Gray Gubler

as Kokava (Jake's lawyer) in Murder Between Friends

Score: 0

Nathan Fillion

as Henry's Dad in Murder Between Friends

Score: +2

Disney Plus and Hulu

as Streaming service in Murder Between Friends

Score: +4

Breckin Meyer

as Grace's father in Murder Between Friends

Score: +2

Jerry O'Connell

as Paul in Weapons 2001

Score: +1

Cloris Leachman

as Aunt Gladys in Weapons 2001

Score: +1

Kurt Russell

as Archer Graff in Weapons 2001

Score: +1

BD Wong

as Principal Marcus Miller in Weapons 2001

Score: +1

Cole Sprouse

as Alex Lily in Weapons 2001

Score: +1

Brittany Murphy

as Mrs. Justine Gandy in Weapons 2001

Score: +1

Joe Keery

as Bobby in What's Eating Gilbert Grape

Score: +1

Lucas Till

as Tucker in What's Eating Gilbert Grape

Score: +1

Kristen Bell

as Betty Carver in What's Eating Gilbert Grape

Score: 0

Rita Wilson

as Becky's Grandmother in What's Eating Gilbert Grape

Score: +1

Madeleine McGraw

as Ellen Grape in What's Eating Gilbert Grape

Score: +2