Suggestions by @hawkbloc

Ben McKenzie

as Nancy’s Dad in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Rian Johnson

as Nancy’s Dad in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Danny McBride

as Nancy’s Dad in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Lia McHugh

as Nancy’s Sister in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Katie Silverman

as Nancy’s Sister in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Emma Shannon

as Nancy’s Sister in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Wesley Snipes

as Inkanyamba in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Moritz Pauli

as Carolyn’s Brother (18) in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Casey Simpson

as Carolyn’s Brother (18) in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Caleb Johnston-Miller

as Carolyn’s Brother (14) in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Cameron Crovetti

as Carolyn’s Brother (14) in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Christian Convery

as Carolyn’s Brother (14) in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Thomas Parobek

as Carolyn’s Brother (10) in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Dean Woodward

as Carolyn’s Brother (10) in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Valorie Curry

as Mrs. Johnson in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Emily Kinney

as Mrs. Johnson in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Christy Carlson Romano

as Mrs. Johnson in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Melissa Benoist

as Mrs. Johnson in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1

Mike Vogel

as Mr. Johnson in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: +1

Luke Hemsworth

as Mr. Johnson in Final Girl Characters(story private)

Score: -1