Suggestions by @hannyilin

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Daniel Dreiberg in Watchmen reboot

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Edward Morgan Blake in Watchmen reboot

Score: 0

Dan Stevens

as Walter Kovac in Watchmen reboot

Score: 0

Scott Adkins

as Walter Kovac in Watchmen reboot

Score: +2

Denzel Washington

as Jonathan Osterman in Watchmen reboot

Score: -1

David Fincher

as Director in Watchmen reboot

Score: +1

Stephen Lang

as Abraham Whistler in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Deacon Frost in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Mia Goth

as Lilith in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Cara Delevingne

as Ana Hellstrom in Midnight Sons

Score: 0

Gabriel Luna

as Robbie Reyes in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Kit Harington

as Dane Whitman in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Gael García Bernal

as Jack Russell in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Sacha Baron Cohen

as Mephisto in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Zachary Quinto

as Black Heart in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Tom Ellis

as Black Heart in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Finn Jones

as Danny Rand in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Norman Reedus

as Danny Ketch in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Daredevil (Charlie Cox)

as Matthew Murdock in Midnight Sons

Score: +1

Jared Leto

as Michael Morbius in Midnight Sons

Score: +1