Suggestions by @grace_somethin

Olivia Rodrigo

as Haley James-Scott in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: +5

Rachel Zegler

as Haley James-Scott in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: 0

Spence Moore II

as Ferggie in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: +1

Sean Giambrone

as Marvin(Mouth)McFadden in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: 0

Marcel Ruiz

as Marvin(Mouth)McFadden in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: -2

Forrest Wheeler

as Marvin(Mouth)McFadden in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: -3

Rudy Pankow

as Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: +5

Uriah Shelton

as Nathan Scott in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: -2

Matt Cornett

as Nathan Scott in One Tree Hill - 2022 Reboot

Score: +3

Mark Wahlberg

as Nathan Scott in One Tree Hill (1993-2002)

Score: -1

Lizzy Greene

as Lydia Bob Scott in One Tree Hill: The Next Generation

Score: +3

Noah Schnapp

as Jude Norris Baker in One Tree Hill: The Next Generation

Score: +1

Asher Angel

as Jude Norris Baker in One Tree Hill: The Next Generation

Score: +1

Joshua Bassett

as James Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill: The Next Generation

Score: +4

Jacob Bertrand

as James Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill: The Next Generation

Score: +4

Griffin Gluck

as James Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill: The Next Generation

Score: -2

Will Buie Jr.

as Mike Teavee in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Movie Musical

Score: +1

Archie Yates

as Augustus Gloop in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Movie Musical

Score: +1

Wyatt McClure

as Augustus Gloop in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Movie Musical

Score: +1

Amber Riley

as Mrs. Gloop in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Movie Musical

Score: +1