Suggestions by @grace_somethin

Mila Kunis

as Maeve Rojas in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: 0

Vanessa Hudgens

as Bronwyn Rojas in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: +2

Milo Ventimiglia

as Cooper Clay in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: 0

Milo Ventimiglia

as Nate McAuley in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: -1

Jared Padalecki

as Cooper Clay in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: 0

Chad Michael Murray

as Cooper Clay in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: 0

James Lafferty

as Nate McAuley in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: -1

Jared Padalecki

as Nate McAuley in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: -1

Josh Hartnett

as Nate McAuley in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: -1

Mila Kunis

as Bronwyn Rojas in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: -1

Elisha Cuthbert

as Addy Prentiss in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: -1

Lizzy Caplan

as Janae in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: +1

Jonathan Bennett

as TJ Forester in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: +1

Matt Czuchry

as Jake Riorden in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: +1

Mandy Moore

as Keely in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: +1

Orlando Bloom

as Luis in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: +1

Adam Brody

as Simon Kelleher in One of Us is Lying (2000s Casting)

Score: +1