Suggestions by @goophaha

Nell Campbell

as Max in Evilx3 (Rocky Horror Edition)

Score: +1

Richard O'Brien

as Zach in Evilx3 (Rocky Horror Edition)

Score: +1

Peter Hinwood

as Buff Guy in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Brandon Rogers

as Richard in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

John Mulaney

as Gex in Gex: The Animated Series

Score: 0

Ryan Reynolds

as Mac in Mac and me goop edition

Score: +1

Jason Momoa

as Buff Guy in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: -1

Jinkx Monsoon

as The Queen Who Shall Not Be Named in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Sayantani Guhathakurta

as Steves Mom in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Zach Hadel

as Steves Mom in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: -1

Willem Dafoe

as Richards dad in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: -1

Joshua Tomar

as Steve in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: -1

Joshua Tomar

as Richard in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: -1

Tim Curry

as Richards dad in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Seth Rogen

as Nickotine in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Seth Rogan

as Nickotine in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: -1

William Finley

as Goop in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Meowthamy in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Emma Watson

as Diana in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1

Harvey Guillén

as Steve in Spooky Scary Transmansion

Score: +1