Suggestions by @gonzalopardo

Morena Baccarin

as Charlotte "Charlie" Harris in Haunted Night trilogy by Wes Craven (2003 - 2007)

Score: -1

James McAvoy

as Henry Summers in Haunted Night trilogy by Wes Craven (2003 - 2007)

Score: -1

Adam Brody

as Shaun Hudson in Haunted Night trilogy by Wes Craven (2003 - 2007)

Score: -1

Josh Hutcherson

as Dick Lawless in The Skystar Tetralogy by J. J. Abrams (2001 - 2020)

Score: -1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Jack Lawless in The Skystar Tetralogy by J. J. Abrams (2001 - 2020)

Score: -1

Michelle Williams

as Loraine Arsen in The Skystar Tetralogy by J. J. Abrams (2001 - 2020)

Score: -1

Michael Rooker

as Zeke Robertson in The Skystar Tetralogy by J. J. Abrams (2001 - 2020)

Score: +1

Josh Hutcherson

as Jack Lawless in The Skystar Tetralogy by J. J. Abrams (2001 - 2020)

Score: +1

Jack Earle Haley

as Zeke Robertson in The Skystar Tetralogy by J. J. Abrams (2001 - 2020)

Score: -1

Bradley Cooper

as Skystar in Paragon Requiem

Score: +2

Jason Ritter

as Cameron Lawless in The Skystar Tetralogy by J. J. Abrams (2001 - 2020)

Score: 0

Jude Law

as Dr. Eignett in Paragón Comics

Score: +1

Jessie Eisenberg

as Crimson Bug in Paragón Comics

Score: -1

Alex Proyas

as Director in Batman Beyond (1998)

Score: +1

Josh Hartnett

as Terry McGinnis in Batman Beyond (1998)

Score: +2

Kristen Bell

as Peregrine in Paragón Comics

Score: +1

Chris Pine

as Quiver in Paragón Comics

Score: -1

Hailee Steinfeld

as Insanity in Paragon Requiem

Score: -1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Spectre in Paragon Requiem

Score: +1

Ross Lynch

as Shaun Hudson in Paragon Requiem

Score: 0