Suggestions by @glennrhee

Jesse Lopez

as From Season 43 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Omar Zaheer

as From Season 42 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Victoria Baamonde

as From season 38 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Davie Rickenbacker

as From Season 37 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Domenick Abbate

as From Season 36 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Devon Pinto

as From Season 35 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Jay Starrett

as From Season 33 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Cydney Gillon

as From Season 32 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Hayden Moss

as From Season 27 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Hayden Moss

as Male Alternate | in Fan-casting A Second “All-Stars“ Survivor Season

Score: +1

Erinn Lobdell

as From Season 18 II in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Sean Rector

as Male Alternate | in Fan-casting A Second “All-Stars“ Survivor Season

Score: +1

Taj Johnson-George

as From Season 18 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Sean Rector

as From Season 4 in Survivor Second Chances II

Score: +1

Clancy Brown

as David Cain in Fan-casting The DCU

Score: +1

Holt McCallany

as David Cain in Fan-casting The DCU

Score: +1

Jessica Stroup

as Selina Kyle in Fan-casting The DCU

Score: +2

Emilia Jones

as Donna Troy in Fan-casting The DCU

Score: +1

Emily Carey

as Donna Troy in Fan-casting The DCU

Score: +1

Deva Cassel

as Donna Troy in Fan-casting The DCU

Score: +1