Suggestions by @gkaran184

Stephen Amell

as Jason Larson in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Scott Speedman

as Jacob Maddox in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Scott Speedman

as Joshua Copeland in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Scott Speedman

as Joshua Copeland in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Luke Bracey

as Tatum in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Élodie Yung

as Chaya in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Gary Oldman

as Richard Copeland in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Britt Robertson

as Gabby in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Justin Chambers

as Dr Xander in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Katheryn Winnick

as Nikki / Lola in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Kevin Rahm

as Nick in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Zachary Levi

as Jeremiah in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Shailene Woodley

as Jane Maddox in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Michael Emerson

as Dr. Gibson in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Christina Scherer

as Zane in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Rene Russo

as Mrs. Montgomery in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Keneth Branagh

as Mr. Montgomery in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Stanley Tucci

as Ernie in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Clint Eastwood

as Popeye in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1

Maggie Lawson

as Liz in Abby Jimenez Universe

Score: +1