Suggestions by @girlhelp
30 suggestions
Kimiko Glenn
as Alexi in Rent(story removed)
Score: +2
Iris Menas
as Michael Mell in Be More Chill(story removed)
Score: 0
Fred Armisen
as Geraldo, a shifty barkeep in the Republic of Pirates in Our Flag Means Death (1992)
Score: +1
Andrew Rannells
as Lucius, a scribe on the Revenge tasked with keeping a record in Our Flag Means Death (1992)
Score: +1
Christian Borle
as Edward Teach aka Blackbeard the legendary pirate captain. in Our Flag Means Death (1992)
Score: +1
Ariana DeBose
as Bonifacia Jimenez/Jim, a skilled fighter in Our Flag Means Death (1992)
Score: -1
Colin O'Donoghue
as William Shakespeare in Something Rotten!
Score: +1
Erika Henningsen
as Maureen Johnson in Rent(story removed)
Score: +2
Jordan Fisher
as Jake Dillinger in Be More Chill(story removed)
Score: +1
Mike Faist
as Jeremy Heere in Be More Chill(story removed)
Score: 0