Suggestions by @gigahank

Joshua Jackson

as J.R. Ewing in Dallas

Score: +1

Joe Bucaro III

as Black Noir in The Boys

Score: +1

Ray Park

as Black Noir in The Boys

Score: +1

Brenda Song

as Kamiko in The Boys

Score: +1

Laura Linney

as Queen Maeve in The Boys

Score: +1

Adam Baldwin

as Black Noir in The Boys

Score: +1

Ashton Kutcher

as A-Train in The Boys

Score: 0

Sean Patrick Thomas

as The Deep in The Boys

Score: +1

Melissa Rauch

as Starlight in The Boys

Score: +1

Reese Witherspoon

as Starlight in The Boys

Score: -1

Patrick Warburton

as The Homelander in The Boys

Score: +1

Doug Jones

as Jack from Jupiter in The Boys

Score: +3

Jason Isaacs

as Billy Butcher in The Boys

Score: +1

Michael C. Hall

as Green Goblin in MCU Spider-Man Villains

Score: +1

Leo Howard

as Dick Grayson in DCU Batman

Score: -4

Cameron Britton

as Pyg in DCU Batman

Score: +3

Leilani Sarelle

as Black Canary in The Burtonverse

Score: +2

Sofia Milos

as Wonder Woman in Justice League (90s TV Series)

Score: 0

John Wesley Shipp

as The Flash in Justice League (90s TV Series)

Score: +2

Trevante Rhodes

as Roadblock in Transformers vs. G.I. Joe (2026)

Score: -2