Suggestions by @gigacarlos

Yuri Lowenthal

as Spiderman in Marvel Daredevil

Score: +1

Ethan Hawke

as Arthur Harrow in Marvel Moon Knight

Score: +1

Yuri Lowenthal

as Spiderman in Marvel Moon Knight

Score: +1

Rob Zombie's Halloween

as Lizard in Spiderman Origins

Score: +1

Thomas Haden Church

as Sandman in Spiderman Origins

Score: +1

Bruce Campbell

as Mysterio in Spiderman Origins

Score: +1

Nancy Linari

as Aunt May in Spiderman Origins

Score: +2

Darin De Paul

as J.Jonah.Jameson in Spiderman Origins

Score: +1

Yuri Lowenthal

as Spiderman in Spiderman Origins

Score: +2

Jeremy Irvine

as Batman in James Gunn's DC Cinematic Universe

Score: -26