Suggestions by @georgeburns

Fuju Kamio

as Shark Puppet Mum in Shark Puppet The Movie

Score: -1

Beste Kökdemir

as Shark Puppet Mum in Shark Puppet The Movie

Score: +1

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Shark Puppet Dad in Shark Puppet The Movie

Score: +1

Katey Sagal

as Shark Puppet (Girl Friend) in Shark Puppet The Movie

Score: +1

Katee Sackhoff

as Shark Puppet (Girl Friend) in Shark Puppet The Movie

Score: +1

Ray Sharkey

as Evil Shark in Shark Puppet The Movie

Score: +2

Stephen Lang

as Shark Puppet in Shark Puppet The Movie

Score: +1

LEGO Star Wars II: The Original Trilogy

as Jack Haley in The Lamb of Oz

Score: +1

Michelle Gomez

as Jack Haley in The Lamb of Oz

Score: -1

Dave Sheridan

as Zuzu in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Paul Bigley

as Muchy the Lunch Bag in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Salih Bademci

as Mayor in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Tyrese Gibson

as Chief's in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

George O. Gore II

as Big Jim in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Jennifer Jason Leigh

as Molly in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Isha Koppikar

as Petey in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Mark Drobot

as 80 HD in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Clancy Brown

as Fippy's in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: -1

Agnetha Fältskog

as Molly in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: +1

Hammam Shafie

as Molly in Dog Man Grime And Punishment

Score: +1