Suggestions by @george84

Tom Hiddleston

as Brutus in Julius Caesar

Score: +1

Christian Bale

as Caesar in Julius Caesar

Score: +2

Marisa Abela

as Vesper Lynd in 007

Score: +1

Joshua J. Parker

as Henry Boyle in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Marc Rissmann

as Fritz Stark in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

LaMonica Garrett

as Patrick in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Sean Harris

as Matthew Greavy in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Billy Magnussen

as Koy Wickman in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Titus Welliver

as Bob Redmond in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Scarlett Johansson

as Short Sally in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Sean Bridgers

as Pete Simpson in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Peter Stormare

as Fritz Stark in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: -1

Thomasin McKenzie

as Billie in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Tom Pelphrey

as Frank Rose in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Logan Marshall-Green

as Cato Tillson in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Peter Mullan

as Zorn Tully in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Damon Herriman

as Eamon O'Malley in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Everett Hitch in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Woody Harrelson

as Virgil Cole in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1

Paul Bettany

as Amos Wolfson in Appaloosa: Resolution

Score: +1