Suggestions by @genesiswipeout

John Mulaney

as Spider ham in Spider-Geddon

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as Spider-Man in Spider-Geddon

Score: +1

Brittany Ishibashi

as Oroku Karai in TMNT 3

Score: +1

Whitney Peak

as Carmen the Conqueror in TMNT 3

Score: +1

Charlie Hunnam

as Green Arrow in Batman: Hush

Score: +2

Andrew Garfield

as Dick Grayson in Batman: Hush

Score: -3

Richard Madden

as Dick Grayson in Batman: Hush

Score: -3

Eric Bana

as Thomas Elliot in Batman: Hush

Score: 0

Javier Bardem

as Bane in Batman: Hush

Score: 0

David Tennant

as Edward Nygma in Batman: Hush

Score: +2

Adam Driver

as Johnathan Crane in Batman: Hush

Score: +1

Jena Malone

as Carrie Kelley in Batman: Hush

Score: +1

Morena Baccarin

as Selina Kyle in Batman: Hush

Score: +2

Bryan Cranston

as Jim Gordon in Batman: Hush

Score: +1

Charles Dance

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Hush

Score: +1

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: Hush

Score: -1

Kevin Conroy

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: Hush

Score: -1

Chris Chalk

as Lucius Fox in The Batman Gotham Follow Up Series

Score: +1

Maggie Geha

as Ivy Pepper in The Batman Gotham Follow Up Series

Score: +1

Nathan Darrow

as Victor Fries in The Batman Gotham Follow Up Series

Score: +1