Suggestions by @gcote

Jim Carrey

as Translucent in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Dennis Quaid

as Hugh Campbell Sr. in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Susan Sarandon

as Madelyn Stillwell in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

David Fincher

as Director in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Billy Bob Thornton

as Producer in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

David Fincher

as Writer in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Jake Lloyd

as Ryan Butcher in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Jennifer Aniston

as Rebecca Butcher in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +2

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Klara Rasinger in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +2

Donnie Yen

as Black Noir in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Lucy Liu

as Kimiko Miyashiro in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Jean Reno

as Serge in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Kevin Moskowitz in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +2

Will Smith

as Reginald Franklin in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Michael Clarke Duncan

as Marvin T. Milk in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Nicole Kidman

as Maggie Shaw in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +2

Alicia Silverstone

as Annie January in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Brad Pitt

as John in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: 0

Seth Green

as Hugh Campbell Jr. in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +1

Mel Gibson

as William Butcher in The Boys (1999 film)

Score: +2