Suggestions by @gagefranke

Doug Jones

as Thing in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +2

Luke Evans

as Gomez Addams in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +2

Eva Green

as Morticia Addams in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +8

Patton Oswalt

as Uncle Fester in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +3

Jeremy Ray Taylor

as Pugsley Addams in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +2

Millie Bobby Brown

as Wednesday Addams in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +1

Tim Burton

as Director in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +3

Lili Reinhart

as Eva Hansen in Dear Eva Hansen

Score: +1

Katherine Langford

as Connie Murphy in Dear Eva Hansen

Score: +1

Tim Burton

as Director in The Candy Man

Score: +1

Tim Robbins

as Grandpa Joe in The Candy Man

Score: 0

Jacob Tremblay

as Charlie Bucket (Kid) in The Candy Man

Score: +2

Katherine Langford

as Emira Blight in The Owl House

Score: -4