Suggestions by @gagefranke

Doug Jones

as Lurch in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +2

Derek Mears

as Lurch in The Addams Family Reboot

Score: +1

Amber Riley

as Bismuth in Steven Universe The Musical

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as Ben Grimm in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +7

Rami Malek

as Silver Surfer in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +2

Keanu Reeves

as Silver Surfer in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +2

Mads Mikkelsen

as Victor Von Doom in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +1

Michael Fassbender

as Victor Von Doom in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +9

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Victor Von Doom in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +1

John Cena

as Ben Grimm in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Ben Grimm in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +1

Dacre Montgomery

as Johnny Storm in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +4

Zac Efron

as Johnny Storm in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +1

John Krasinski

as Reed Richards in Marvel's Fantastic 4

Score: +9

Anthony Mackie

as Captain America in The New Avengers

Score: +3

Liev Schreiber

as Crimson Dynamo in The New Avengers

Score: +2

Bella Heathcote

as Screaming Mimi in The New Avengers

Score: +2

Ana de Armas

as Mystique in The New Avengers

Score: +2

Patton Oswalt

as M.O.D.O.K in The New Avengers

Score: +2

Derek Mears

as Absorbing Man in The New Avengers

Score: +2