Suggestions by @gabrielleelenbaas

Elizabeth Banks

as Cynthia in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Scott Cohen

as Travis Freeland in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +2

Brandy Norwood

as Astrid in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Channing Tatum

as Voodoo Juice Guy in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Carlos Santos

as Rafa in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Lil j

as Javi in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Julia Roberts

as Melanie Freeland in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Adrienne Bailon-Houghton

as Medina in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Tonantzin Esparza

as Medina in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Francia Raísa

as Medina in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Kim Cattrall

as Brooke LaLaine in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Laura Prepon

as Brooke LaLaine in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Keiko Agena

as Yumi in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Cassie Steele

as Noel Ortiz in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

AJ Michalka

as Astrid in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Keke Palmer

as Astrid in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Cody Linley

as Mason Freeland in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Masiela Lusha

as Evie Zamora in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Emily Osment

as Tracy Freeland in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1

Emily Osment

as Tracy Freeland in Thirteen (2006 version)

Score: +1