Suggestions by @frasergodfrey

Sam Witwer

as Deacon St John in Days Gone (Netflix)

Score: +3

Rob Reiner

as Director in Stand By Me (2021)

Score: +1

Jonathan Aris

as The Stranger in Telltale Games' The Walking Dead (Liveaction,TV Series)

Score: 0

Michael Rooker

as James Gordon in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: 0

Matthew Broderick

as Thomas Wayne in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: 0

Carlon Jeffery

as Police Officer 19 in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +1

Tyrone Burton

as Police Officer 91 in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +1

Pedro Campos

as Police Officer 12 in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +1

Bobby Campo

as Police Officer 69 in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +2

Frank Hvam

as Police Officer 58 in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +2

John Paul Tremblay

as Police Officer 29 in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +3

Jay Klaitz

as Lester Crest in GTA Movieverse

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as Superman in Tim Burton’s Justice League (2000)

Score: -3

Jennifer Lawrence

as Katniss Everdeen in Hunger Games: The Phenomenon

Score: +1

Isabela Merced

as Daisy Jonshon in IronMan: The Hero of Iron

Score: 0

Lauren Cohan

as Maria Hill in IronMan: The Hero of Iron

Score: +1

Harold Perrineau

as Nick Fury in IronMan: The Hero of Iron

Score: +1

Adrien Brody

as Howard Stark in IronMan: The Hero of Iron

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Red Skull in IronMan: The Hero of Iron

Score: +1

Tom Ellis

as Bruce Banner in IronMan: The Hero of Iron

Score: +1