Suggestions by @fractalqueen42

Karl Urban

as Peter Lukas in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)

Score: -1

Ronald Reagan

as SCP-1981 in SCP

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as SCP-106 in SCP

Score: +6

Tom Holland

as SCP-049 in SCP

Score: -2

Armie Hammer

as Michael in SCP

Score: +1

Rami Malek

as SCP-073 in SCP The Movie

Score: 0

Margot Robbie

as Dr. Jack Bright (Female) in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: +1

David Mazouz

as SCP-076 in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: +1

Rami Malek

as SCP-073 in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: -1

Mark Hamill

as SCP-047 in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: +1

Scarlett Johansson

as Dr. Sophia Light in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: +2

Henry Cavill

as Lord Theodore Thomas Blackwood in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: -1

Keanu Reeves

as Dr. Alto Clef in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as Dr. Jack Bright (Male) in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: 0

Tom Hardy

as Dr. Cimmerian in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: 0

Armie Hammer

as Doctor Aidan Carlisle in SCP Foundation: The Broken Masquerade

Score: +2

Kim Seung-Han

as Mitsuo Goshima in Uzumaki

Score: +1

Sam Jellie

as Katayama in Uzumaki

Score: +1

Jamie Chung

as Keiko Nakayama in Uzumaki

Score: +1

Tiffany Espensen

as Chie Maruyama in Uzumaki

Score: +1