Suggestions by @flynnmclenan

Will Poulter

as Angel Face in Fight Club (2023)

Score: +1

Aaron Paul

as The Mechanic in Fight Club (2023)

Score: +1

Cary Elwes

as Richard Chesler in Fight Club (2023)

Score: +1

Dacre Montgomery

as Ricky in Fight Club (2023)

Score: +1

Brian Baumgartner

as Robert Paulson in Fight Club (2023)

Score: +1

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Donnie Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Frank in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Gillian Anderson

as Dr. Thurman in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Gretchen Ross in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Antony Starr

as Jim Cunningham in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

James Marsden

as Jim Cunningham in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Alexander Skarsgård

as Jim Cunningham in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Pedro Pascal

as Jim Cunningham in Donnie Darko

Score: -1

Kiernan Shipka

as Elizabeth Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Jenna Ortega

as Elizabeth Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Abigail Cowen

as Elizabeth Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: -1

Mary Elizabeth Winstead

as Karen Pomeroy in Donnie Darko

Score: +2

Jason Bateman

as Eddie Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Sarah Paulson

as Rose Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Diane Keaton

as Grandma Death in Donnie Darko

Score: +1