Suggestions by @flmzbykee

Richard Pryor

as Jackson Hollis in X trilogy if released 1979-1985

Score: +1

Burt Reynolds

as Wayne Gilroy in X trilogy if released 1979-1985

Score: +1

Susan Anton

as Bobby Lynne-Parker in X trilogy if released 1979-1985

Score: +1

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Lorraine Day in X trilogy if released 1979-1985

Score: +1

Shelley Duvall

as Maxine Minx/Pearl in X trilogy if released 1979-1985

Score: +3

Susan Anton

as Maxine Minx/Pearl in X trilogy if released 1979-1985

Score: -1

Sadie Sink

as Kali White in Scream VII

Score: +1

Sadie Sandler

as Kali White in Scream VII

Score: -1

Mason Gooding

as Chad Meeks Martin in Scream VII

Score: +1

Jasmin Savoy Brown

as Mindy Meeks Martin in Scream VII

Score: +1

Melissa Barrera

as Sam Carpenter in Scream VII

Score: +2

Jenna Ortega

as Tara Carpenter in Scream VII

Score: +1

Sofia Carson

as Sam Carpenter/Loomis in Stab (Stab 9)

Score: +1

David Schwimmer

as Dewey Riley in Stab (Stab 9)

Score: +1

Angelina Jolie

as Gale Weathers in Stab (Stab 9)

Score: +1

Tori Spelling

as Sidney Prescott in Stab (Stab 9)

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Mike Wheeler in Stranger Things: A Totally Tubular Reuion

Score: -1

Natalie Portman

as Jane Hopper in Stranger Things: A Totally Tubular Reuion

Score: +5

Claire Danes

as Young Ziggy Berman in Fear Street Trilogy if it was made in 1994

Score: +2

Kate Winslet

as Samantha Fraser / Hannah Miller in Fear Street Trilogy if it was made in 1994

Score: +1