Suggestions by @fionnoconnor402

Aaron Paul

as "Narrator" in Fight Club (2009)

Score: +5

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Tyler Durden in Fight Club (2009)

Score: +8

Mark Boone Junior

as "00 Spool" in Wild at Heart (2000)

Score: +1

Tom Wopat

as Buddy in Wild at Heart (1980)

Score: +1

Jack O'Connell

as Jean-Baptiste Emmanuel Zorg in The Fifth Element (2027)

Score: +1

Glen Powell

as Korben Dallas in The Fifth Element (2027)

Score: +1

John Malkovich

as Count Olaf in A Series of Unfortunate Events (1994)

Score: +1

Stephen Dorff

as Dr. Daniel P. Schreber in Dark City (2008)

Score: +1

Demi Moore

as Emma Murdoch in Dark City (1988)

Score: +1

Nick Stahl

as Piter de Vries in David Lynch's Dune (2014)

Score: +1

Joaquin Phoenix

as Paul Atreides in Dune (2001-2006)

Score: +1

Chris Pine

as Wyatt Earp in Tombstone (2023)

Score: +2

Dominic Monaghan

as Brother Swan in Mandy (2028)

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Sheriff George Bannerman in The Dead Zone (2003)

Score: +2

Steve Carell

as Peevy A. Peabody in The Rocketeer (2021)

Score: +2

Grant Gustin

as Cliff Secord in The Rocketeer (2021)

Score: +2

James Gandolfini

as Eddie Valentino in The Rocketeer (2011)

Score: +2

Gerard Butler

as Logan Howlett in The X-Men (1999)

Score: +4

Ian Holm

as Dr. Montgomery Montgomery in A Series of Unfortunate Events (1994)

Score: +1

Brittany Murphy

as Violet Baudelaire in A Series of Unfortunate Events (1994)

Score: +1