Suggestions by @fionnoconnor402

Jeff Bridges

as Adam Maitland in Beetlejuice (1978)

Score: +1

Isabella Rossellini

as Mandy Bloom in Mandy (1988)

Score: +1

Taylor Kitsch

as Howard Hughes in The Rocketeer (2024)

Score: +2

Max von Sydow

as Jeremiah Sand in Mandy (1988)

Score: +1

Jack Nicholson

as Red Miller in Mandy (1988)

Score: +2

Dennis Hopper

as Red Miller in Mandy (1988)

Score: +3

Bobby Cannavale

as Eddie Valentine in The Rocketeer (2024)

Score: +2

Rupert Friend

as Neville Sinclair in The Rocketeer (2024)

Score: +2

Millie Bobby Brown

as Jenny Blake in The Rocketeer (2024)

Score: +3

Willem Dafoe

as 2000s in Who could’ve played Max Shreck?

Score: +6

Nicolas Cage

as 2010s in Who could’ve played Max Shreck?

Score: +5

John C. Reilly

as A. Peevy Ambrose in The Rocketeer (2024)

Score: +3

Lewis Pullman

as Cliff Secord in The Rocketeer (2024)

Score: +5

David Corenswet

as Cliff Secord in The Rocketeer (2024)

Score: +5

Jacob Elordi

as Ray Bronson in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2017)

Score: +1

Will Poulter

as Barry Cox in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2017)

Score: +1

Erin Moriarty

as Helen Shivers in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2017)

Score: +1

Mikey Madison

as Julie James in I Know What You Did Last Summer (2017)

Score: +2

Alicia Silverstone

as Cassandra Howard in Euphoria (1999-2002)

Score: +3

Jennifer Love Hewitt

as Alexis Howard in Euphoria (1999-2002)

Score: +4