Suggestions by @fionnoconnor402

Tom Selleck

as Barton Blaze in Ghost Rider (1997)

Score: +1

Famke Janssen

as Vivienne Nimue, the Blood Queen in Neil Marshall's Hellboy (2009)

Score: +2

Liev Schreiber

as Hellboy / Anung-Un-Rama in Neil Marshall's Hellboy (2009)

Score: +2

Richard Griffiths

as Arthur Poe in A Series of Unfortunate Events (1994)

Score: +1

Timothy Spall

as Apothecary in Romeo + Juliet (2016)

Score: +1

Christopher Eccleston

as Father Laurence in Romeo + Juliet (2016)

Score: +1

Meg Foster

as Mother Marlene in Mandy (2008)

Score: +1

Richard Harris

as Baltus Van Tassel in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +2

Meg Foster

as Lady Mary Van Tassel in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +3

Uma Thurman

as Katrina Van Tassel in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +2

Udo Kier

as Mayor Landis in Dinosaurs of the Dead

Score: +2

Gregory Peck

as Peter Van Garrett in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +2

Isabella Rossellini

as Lady Crane in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +2

Lukas Haas

as Young Masbath in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +3

Sebastian Shaw

as Notary James Hardenbrook in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +3

Ian Holm

as Dr. Thomas Lancaster in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +2

M. Emmet Walsh

as Magistrate Samuel Philipse in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +2

George Segal

as Reverend Steenwyck in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +4

Billy Campbell

as Brom Van Brunt in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +5

Michael Caine

as Baltus Van Tassel in Sleepy Hollow (1989)

Score: +5