Suggestions by @filmeinstein

James Corden

as Mr. Smee in Hook (Will Ferrell Movie)

Score: 0

Brie Larson

as Sarah in Love Actually

Score: +1

Brett Goldstein

as Jamie in Love Actually

Score: +1

Josh Gad

as Max Bialystock in The Producers (Broadway 2026)

Score: +1

Laurence Fishburne

as Mr. Mertle in The Sandlot

Score: +1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Mole in Wind in the Willows

Score: +2

James McAvoy

as Rat in Wind in the Willows

Score: -1

Gary Oldman

as Mr. Badger in Wind in the Willows

Score: -1

Eddie Redmayne

as Mr. Toad in Wind in the Willows

Score: -1

Jeff Bergman

as Beaky Buzzard in Bugs Bunny's Hare Brained New Year's Eve Special

Score: +1

Bill Pullman

as Billy Bailey in It's a Wonderful Life

Score: +1

Benedict Wong

as George Aaronow in Glengarry Glen Ross (Korean Cast)

Score: +2

Mikey Madison

as Penelope Wilhern in Penelope Remake

Score: +1

Peter Capaldi

as Jacob Marley in A Christmas Carol (2022)

Score: +2

Michael Keaton

as Preston Rhinelander in Scrooged

Score: +1

Glen Powell

as Frank Cross in Scrooged

Score: +1

Paul Rudd

as Miracle Max in The Princess Bride

Score: +2