Suggestions by @filmboxx2

Molly Stanton

as Peach in If Super Mario 2 live action made in 2012

Score: +1

Bobby Roode

as Bowser suit in If Super Mario 2 live action made in 2012

Score: +1

Trent Redekop

as Wario in If Super Mario 2 live action made in 2012

Score: +1

Jesse Bradford

as Luigi in If Super Mario 2 live action made in 2012

Score: +1

Josh Server

as Mario in If Super Mario 2 live action made in 2012

Score: +1

Josh Server

as Mario in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Brian Henson

as Director 2 in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Guillermo del Toro

as Director in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Simon Baker

as Pronto in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Miguel Sandoval

as Salvador Drainotto in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Keith D. Robinson

as Robert Littel in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Carlin James

as Toad in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Bobby Roode

as Bowser Suit in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Molly Stanton

as Princess Peach in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Jesse Bradford

as Luigi in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +1

Andrew-Lee Potts

as Mario in If Super Mario live action movie was made in 2009

Score: +2