Suggestions by @fernando1997

Kaitlyn Dever

as Robin/Carrie Kelly in Batman Dark Knight Returns

Score: +1

Tom Cruise

as Harvey Dent/Two-face in Batman Dark Knight Returns

Score: +1

David Corenswet

as Superman in Batman Dark Knight Returns

Score: +1

Brad Pitt

as Batman in Batman Dark Knight Returns

Score: +1

Harry Lawtey

as Nathaniel Stromler in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: +1

E. Roger Mitchell

as Patch Up in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: -1

Wendell Pierce

as Patch Up in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: -1

Chad Coleman

as Patch Up in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: +1

Henry Zaga

as Cole Burns in 100 Bullets

Score: +1

Henrique Zaga

as Cole Burns in 100 Bullets

Score: +1

Harry Goodwins

as Wylie Times in 100 Bullets

Score: +1

Alex Ferns

as Mr. Branch in 100 Bullets

Score: +1

Zahn McClarnon

as Deep Lakes in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: +1

Ralph Ineson

as John Lawrence Pugford in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: +1

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Long Clay in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: +1

Toby Wallace

as Brent Pugford in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: -1

Harris Dickinson

as Nathaniel Stromler in Wraiths of a Broken Land

Score: -1

Rossif Sutherland

as Kelso in Heat 2

Score: -1

Evan Jones

as Hank Svoboda in Heat 2

Score: -1

Sam Reid

as Diesel in Scalped

Score: +1