Suggestions by @feliciahardy01

Michael Stuhlbarg

as Lex Luthor in Superman: For All Seasons

Score: +2

Michelle Williams

as Lois Lane in Superman: For All Seasons

Score: +2

Chosen Jacobs

as Clark Kent (young) in Superman: For All Seasons

Score: 0

Winston Duke

as Superman in Superman: For All Seasons

Score: 0

Kelly Reichardt

as Director in Superman: For All Seasons

Score: 0

Michael Shannon

as Stan Lee in Stan Lee biopic

Score: +2

Jeremy Strong

as Frederick Chilton in Red Dragon

Score: +5

Marilee Talkington

as Reba McClane in Red Dragon

Score: +2

Jesse Plemons

as Freddy Lounds in Red Dragon

Score: +2

Evan Rachel Wood

as Molly Graham in Red Dragon

Score: +3

Woody Harrelson

as Jack Crawford in Red Dragon

Score: +2

Ben Foster

as Francis Dolarhyde in Red Dragon

Score: +2

Colin Farrell

as Hannibal Lecter in Red Dragon

Score: +1

Adam Driver

as Will Graham in Red Dragon

Score: +2

Cary Joji Fukunaga

as Director in Red Dragon

Score: +2

Crispin Glover

as Uncle Fester in The Addams Family

Score: +4

Matthew McConaughey

as Good Casting, Bad Writing in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Score: +13

Toni Collette

as Norma "Mother" Bates (voice) in Psycho (2020)

Score: +2

Florence Pugh

as Lila Crane in Psycho (2020)

Score: +1

Ari Aster

as Director in Psycho (2020)

Score: +2