Suggestions by @fantasticbeasts

Dan Fogler

as Fester in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Daniel Radcliffe

as Mal Beineke in The Addams Family: A New Musical

Score: +1

Christian Convery

as Pugsley Addams in The Addams Family: A New Musical

Score: +1

Fiona Shaw

as Grandma Addams in The Addams Family: A New Musical

Score: +1

Julie Walters

as Grandma Addams in The Addams Family: A New Musical

Score: +1

Jackie Hoffman

as Grandma Addams in The Addams Family: A New Musical

Score: +1

Kristen Bell

as Lucas’s Mother in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Lucy Boynton

as Alice Beineke in The Addams Family: A New Musical

Score: +1

Ellie Kemper

as Lucas’s Mother in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Bowen Yang

as Fester in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Tituss Burgess

as Fester in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: 0

Lucy Boynton

as Lucas’s Mother in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Tanner Buchanan

as Lucas in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: 0

Milo Manheim

as Lucas in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Kit Connor

as Lucas in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Christian Convery

as Pugsley in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Julie Walters

as Grandmama in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Fiona Shaw

as Grandmama in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2

Jackie Hoffman

as Grandmama in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: 0

Helena Bonham Carter

as Morticia in The Addams Family: The Musical

Score: +2