Suggestions by @fancastdceu
1,373 suggestions

Edy Ganem
as Aubrey Sparks in Martian Manhunter

Norman Reedus
as Hogarth Kane in Martian Manhunter

Ron Perlman
as Chief Keane in Martian Manhunter

Michael Ealy
as Mica'kel in Martian Manhunter

Michael Jai White
as A'monn A'mokk in Martian Manhunter

Birgundi Baker
as Cay'an/Sara Moore in Martian Manhunter

Lewis Pullman
as Alex Ferguson in Martian Manhunter

Dania Ramirez
as Rio Ferdinand in Martian Manhunter

Laura Dern
as Diane Meade in Martian Manhunter

Halle Berry
as A'morr A'mokk in Martian Manhunter

Savannah Smith
as M'gann M'orzz/Megan Morse in Martian Manhunter

David Gyasi
as J'onn J'onzz/John Jones in Martian Manhunter

Rob Raco
as Carlo di Rienzi in Zatanna

Giacomo Gianniotti
as Giovanni Zatara in Zatanna

Ana Brenda Contreras
as Jenny Myers in Zatanna

Raja Gemini
as Hypnota in Zatanna

Ricky Martin
as Gregorio de la Vega in Zatanna

Cody H. Carolin
as Mikey Dowling in Zatanna

Dustin Milligan
as Arnie in Zatanna

Vanessa Anne Williams
as Bunny in Zatanna