Suggestions by @eyricelovely

Eleven

as Shannen Doherty in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +4

Lisa Swallows

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +4

Ashley (Disventure Camp)

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +4

Rose Cinderella

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +4

Isabel Armstrong (Unicorn Academy)

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +3

Stella (Winx Club)

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +3

Iris(Lolirock)

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +3

Helen (Little Tiaras)

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +3

Snowy (Fantasy Patrol)

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +3

Princess Merlinda

as Olivia D'abo in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +3

Jenna (My Fault)

as Lisa Bonet in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1984?

Score: +3

Terry (Sorority Girl)

as Sosie Bacon in Which characters should actors have played in the 2010s?

Score: +3

Stacey Albright

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3

Claire Davis (Prom Night 2008)

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3

Samantha Fraser

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3

Lila Rossi

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3

Chloe (Tamara 2005)

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3

Tina Turnbow

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3

Emmy Golden

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3

Gretchen Wieners (2024)

as Christina Ricci in Which characters should actors have played in the year 1999?

Score: +3