Suggestions by @evaweaver

Malcolm McDowell

as Dr. Hayes in Looking for Alaska

Eric Dane

as Mr. Starnes in Looking for Alaska

Dakota Fanning

as Alaska Young in Looking for Alaska

Pam Ferris

as Mitsy in Hidden Pictures

Diego Luna

as Adrien in Hidden Pictures

Idris Elba

as Russell in Hidden Pictures

Zoë Renee

as Mallory Quinn in Hidden Pictures

Colin Firth

as Ted Maxwell in Hidden Pictures

Chris Noth

as Ted Maxwell in Hidden Pictures

Emily Blunt

as Caroline Maxwell in Hidden Pictures

Margot Robbie

as Caroline Maxwell in Hidden Pictures

Charley Webb

as Caroline Maxwell in Hidden Pictures

Hugo Lavoie

as Teddy in Hidden Pictures

Luke Grimes

as Grim in Things We Never Got Over

Alexander Dreymon

as Grim in Things We Never Got Over

Emilia Clarke

as Naomi in Things We Never Got Over

Dean Winchester

as Knox in Things We Never Got Over

Chris Zylka

as Warner in Things We Never Got Over

Ryan Phillippe

as Warner in Things We Never Got Over

I Know What You Did Last Summer

as Warner in Things We Never Got Over