Suggestions by @etmay

Peter Behn

as Brian in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Donnie Dunagan

as Warlock Dowling in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Glyn Dearman

as Wensleydale in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Mervyn Johns

as Aziraphale in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: -2

Alastair Sim

as Hastur in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Porter Hall

as Mr Young in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: -1

Beulah Bondi

as Agnes Nutter in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Joan Carroll

as Pepper in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Nigel Bruce

as Mr Young in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: -1

Vincent Price

as Famine in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Billie Burke

as Madame Tracy in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Margaret Hamilton

as Agnes Nutter in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Bert Lahr

as Greaser in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Claude Rains

as Mr Tyler in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Dwight Frye

as Ligur in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Ernest Thesiger

as Dagon in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Henry Travers

as Aziraphale in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: -2

David Tomlinson

as Newton Pulsifer in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Vincent Price

as Death in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1

Frank Morgan

as Shadwell in Good Omens (Old Hollywood Edition)

Score: +1