Suggestions by @ethelthecreator

Taylour Paige

as It Followed Me Home in SHIVER

Score: +4

Riley Keough

as It Followed Me Home in SHIVER

Score: +4

Justice Smith

as It Followed Me Home in SHIVER

Score: +3

Janelle Monáe

as It Followed Me Home in SHIVER

Score: +4

Troye Sivan

as It Followed Me Home in SHIVER

Score: +3

Willem Dafoe

as Charon's Transit in SHIVER

Score: +4

Anthony Ramos

as Charon's Transit in SHIVER

Score: +6

Julia Fox

as Charon's Transit in SHIVER

Score: +4

Paul Giamatti

as Charon's Transit in SHIVER

Score: +5

Ariana Grande

as Charon's Transit in SHIVER

Score: +4

David Dastmalchian

as Charon's Transit in SHIVER

Score: +4

Colman Domingo

as Charon's Transit in SHIVER

Score: +4

Daniel Kaluuya

as Ben Grimm in The Silver Surfer

Score: +2

Reneé Rapp

as Squirrel Girl in Squirrel Girl vs. The Universe

Score: +2

Trey Edward Shults

as Director in The Silver Surfer

Score: +1

Julia Stiles

as Medusa in The Silver Surfer

Score: +2

Ben Barnes

as Black Bolt in The Silver Surfer

Score: +1

Garrett Hedlund

as Thor Odinson in The Silver Surfer

Score: +2

John David Washington

as Heimdall in The Silver Surfer

Score: +2

Matty Matheson

as Rocket Raccoon in The Silver Surfer

Score: +2