Suggestions by @erikhillenburg

Ted Lewis

as Lewis Powell in Histeria!: Alternate Version

John Goodman

as George Atzerodt in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Jason Marsden

as William Ramsey in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Luke Ruegger

as Newman Darby in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Harry Shearer

as Davy Crockett in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Pamela Anderson

as Pamela Anderson in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Wayne Gretzky

as Wayne Gretzky in Histeria!: Alternate Version

John Cleese

as John McDonald in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Phil LaMarr

as Charles Dickens in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Kevin Michael Richardson

as William Dean Howells in Histeria!: Alternate Version

André Sogliuzzo

as Kenneth Grahame in Histeria!: Alternate Version

John Cleese

as Washington Irving in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Dan Castellaneta

as Benjamin Harrison V in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Billy West

as Henry Lee III in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Joel McCrary

as Gilbert Carlton Walker in Histeria!: Alternate Version

John Cleese

as Frederick W. M. Holliday in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Robin Atkin Downes

as William E. Cameron in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Corey Burton

as Philip W. McKinney in Histeria!: Alternate Version

André Sogliuzzo

as Claude A. Swanson in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Jim Cummings

as Charles Triplett O'Ferrall in Histeria!: Alternate Version