Suggestions by @erikhillenburg

Luke Ruegger

as Thorstein Eiriksson in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Mark Harmon

as Odysseus in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Aaron Lustig

as Sir James Matthew Barrie in Histeria!: Alternate Version

Nathan Ruegger

as Froggo in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Cody Ruegger

as Loud Kiddington in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Laraine Newman

as Miss Information in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Debi Derryberry

as Pepper Mills in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Tara Strong

as Big Fat Baby in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Frank Welker

as Fetch in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Rob Paulsen

as Sammy Melman in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Candi Milo

as Charity Bazaar in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Frank Welker

as Father Time in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Laraine Newman

as Cho-Cho in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Billy West

as Chit Chatterson in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Tress MacNeille

as World's Oldest Woman in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Jeff Bennett

as Lucky Bob in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Nora Dunn

as Lydia Karaoke in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Cree Summer

as Aka Pella in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Michael Gough

as Bill Straitman in Histeria!: Historical Fun

Tress MacNeille

as Toast in Histeria!: Historical Fun