Suggestions by @epimetheus2020

Keanu Reeves

as Squip in Be More Chill

Score: +1

Lana Condor

as Christine Canigula in Be More Chill

Score: +2

Devin Druid

as Jeremy Heere in Be More Chill

Score: +1

John Carpenter

as Composer in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Edgar Wright

as Director in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Tobin Bell

as Thomas X Wickley in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Danny Glover

as Captain Al (older) in Meddling Kids

Score: +2

Michael B. Jordan

as Captain al (younger) in Meddling Kids

Score: +2

Daniel Dae Kim

as Sheriff Copperseed in Meddling Kids

Score: 0

Oakes Fegley

as Joey Krantz (age 13) in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Jaeden Martell

as Peter Manner (age 13) in Meddling Kids

Score: +3

Jack Gore

as Nate Rogers (age 11) in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Kerri Hollis (age 12) in Meddling Kids

Score: +6

Breanna Yde

as Andy Rodriguez (age 12) in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Fiona Dourif

as Duina Deboen in Meddling Kids

Score: +3

Brad Dourif

as Damien Deboen in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Alex Russell

as Joey Krantz (age 26) in Meddling Kids

Score: +1

Nick Robinson

as Peter manner (age 26) in Meddling Kids

Score: 0

Dylan Minnette

as Nate Rogers (age 23) in Meddling Kids

Score: -1

Mackenzie Davis

as Kerri Hollis (age 25) in Meddling Kids

Score: +1