Suggestions by @enolaeleven

Ian McKellen

as Julian Morrow in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Ewan McGregor

as Francis Abernathy in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +1

Domhnall Gleeson

as Francis Abernathy in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +1

Damian Lewis

as Francis Abernathy in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +2

Uma Thurman

as Camilla Macaulay in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Diane Kruger

as Camilla Macaulay in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Naomi Watts

as Camilla Macaulay in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Cate Blanchett

as Camilla Macaulay in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Ewan McGregor

as Bunny Corcoran in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Bunny Corcoran in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +1

Matt Damon

as Bunny Corcoran in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +2

Alexander Skarsgård

as Charles Macaulay in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Brad Pitt

as Charles Macaulay in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Charles Macaulay in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

James McAvoy

as Henry Winter in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Jude Law

as Henry Winter in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Eric Roberts

as Henry Winter in The Secret History (90s)

Score: -1

Keanu Reeves

as Richard Papen in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Richard Papen in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +1

Edward Norton

as Richard Papen in The Secret History (90s)

Score: +1