Suggestions by @emthewitch

Jacob Elordi

as Rob Valencia in Bunny

Score: 0

Mia Goth

as Kira Stone in Bunny

Score: +3

Sydney Sweeney

as Caroline Anderson in Bunny

Score: 0

Hailee Steinfeld

as Samantha Heather Mackey in Bunny

Score: +2

Taylor Momsen

as Ava in Bunny

Score: -1

Lily Newmark

as Victoria Fielding in Bunny

Score: +6

Johnny Depp

as Alan Reid in Bunny

Score: -1

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Alan Reid in Bunny

Score: +3

Hunter Schafer

as Eleanor Brown in Bunny

Score: +2

Ester Expósito

as Eleanor Brown in Bunny

Score: +1

Madelaine Petsch

as Victoria Fielding in Bunny

Score: -1

Lucy Boynton

as Caroline Anderson in Bunny

Score: +1

Camilla Morrone

as Samantha Heather Mackey in Bunny

Score: +2

Ester Expósito

as Eleanor Brown in Bunny

Score: +3

Hunter Schafer

as Eleanor Brown in Bunny

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Kira Stone in Bunny

Score: +1

Lucy Boynton

as Caroline Anderson in Bunny

Score: +1

Madelaine Petsch

as Victoria Fielding in Bunny

Score: 0

Evan Peters

as Jonah in Bunny

Score: +3

Maya Hawke

as Ava in Bunny

Score: +2