Suggestions by @emilycareyfan

Isaiah Russell-Bailey

as Best Original Superhero in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Nathan Blair

as Best Original Superhero in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Andy Walken

as Best Original Superhero in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Pedro Pascal

as Worst Villain in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

YaYa Gosselin

as Best Original Superhero in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings

Rolfe Kent

as Composer in She's All That

Livia De Paolis

as Writer in She's All That

Bill Block

as Producer in She's All That

Mark Waters

as Director in She's All That

Rachael Leigh Cook

as Lois Siler in She's All That

Matthew Lillard

as Principal Stickley in She's All That

Isaak Presley

as Derek Funkhouser Rutley in She's All That

Dylan O'Brien

as Mitch in She's All That

Sharon Leal

as Ms. Rousseau in She's All That

Freddie Prinze Jr.

as Harlan Siler in She's All That

Ariela Barer

as Misty in She's All That

Kerris Dorsey

as Chandler in She's All That

Quincy Fouse

as Preston in She's All That

Camille Hyde

as Katarina Darlingson in She's All That

Tati Gabrielle

as Alex Chason Sawyer in She's All That