Suggestions by @emerythrower

Natalie Portman

as Sidney Prescott in Scream 7

Score: +1

Christopher Judge

as Ghostface in Scream 7

Score: +1

Christopher Judge

as Ghostface in Scream 7

Score: -1

James McAvoy

as Stu Macher in Scream 7

Score: +1

Norman Reedus

as Dewey Riley in Scream 7

Score: +2