Suggestions by @emelina2005

Brandon Spink

as Matt Kelner in THE SHARDS

Score: -1

Michael Cimino

as Thom Wright in THE SHARDS

Score: +1

Cooper van Grootel

as Robert Mallory in THE SHARDS

Score: -2

Cory Michael Smith

as Steven Reinhart in THE SHARDS

Score: +2

Toni Collette

as Liz Schaffer in THE SHARDS

Score: +2

Wolfgang Novogratz

as Ryan Vaughan in THE SHARDS

Score: +1

Odessa Young

as Debbie Schaffer in THE SHARDS

Score: 0

Warren Kole

as Terry Schaffer in THE SHARDS

Score: +2

Jack Champion

as Bret Ellis in THE SHARDS

Score: +3

Benedetta Porcaroli

as Susan Reynolds in THE SHARDS

Score: +1

Paul Mescal

as Steven Reinhart in THE SHARDS

Score: 0

Felix Mallard

as Matt Kelner in THE SHARDS

Score: -3

Damian Hardung

as Thom Wright in THE SHARDS

Score: +3

Dylan Sprayberry

as Robert Mallory in THE SHARDS

Score: +1

Chloë Sevigny

as Liz Schaffer in THE SHARDS

Score: +3

Brandon Butler

as Ryan Vaughan in THE SHARDS

Score: +3

Maia Reficco

as Debbie Schaffer in THE SHARDS

Score: -1

Mark Consuelos

as Terry Schaffer in THE SHARDS

Score: +3

Xolo Maridueña

as Bret Ellis in THE SHARDS

Score: 0

Judah Lewis

as Eddie Munster in The Chalk Man

Score: +1