Suggestions by @elmacho

Rachel Zegler

as Noemi Taboada in Mexican Gothic

Score: -1

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Adult Jack Sawyer in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Julian Hilliard

as Jack Sawyer in The Talisman / Black House

Score: -1

Jude Hill

as Richard Sloat in The Talisman / Black House

Score: -1

Judah Prehn

as Richard Sloat in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Owen Cooper

as Jack Sawyer in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +2

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Wolf in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Wolf in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Henry Thomas

as Morgan Sloat in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Kate Siegel

as Lily Cavanaugh Sawyer in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Carl Lumbly

as Speedy Parker in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Alden Ehrenreich

as Adult Jack Sawyer in The Talisman / Black House

Score: -1

Christian Convery

as Richard Sloat in The Talisman / Black House

Score: -1

Colin O'Brien

as Jack Sawyer in The Talisman / Black House

Score: -1

Joe Freeman

as Jack Sawyer in The Talisman / Black House

Score: +1

Laura Harrier

as Susannah Dean in The Dark Tower series

Score: +1

Sophia Di Martino

as Becka Paulson in The Tommyknockers

Score: +1

Kathryn Hahn

as Sheriff Ruth Merrill in The Tommyknockers

Score: -1

Laura Dern

as Sheriff Ruth Merrill in The Tommyknockers

Score: -1

Elisabeth Moss

as Sheriff Ruth Merrill in The Tommyknockers

Score: +1