Suggestions by @elizabethtaylor
237 suggestions
Matthew McConaughey
as Petruchio in The Taming of the Shrew
Score: -1
Brian d'Arcy James
as Shrek in Shrek (Live Action)(story removed)
Score: 0
Sutton Foster
as Princess Fiona in Shrek (Live Action)(story removed)
Score: +3
Eddie Murphy
as Donkey in Shrek (Live Action)(story removed)
Score: +6
Paul Rudd
as Joe in Some Like It Hot
Score: 0
James Marsden
as Jerry in Some Like It Hot
Score: -1
Ian McShane
as Spats Columbo in Some Like It Hot
Score: +2
Oscar Isaac
as Hades in Greek Myths(story removed)
Score: -2
Dan Stevens
as Prince Lir in The Last Unicorn
Score: 0
Christopher Lee
as King Haggard in The Last Unicorn
Score: +3
Helena Bonham Carter
as Molly Grue in The Last Unicorn
Score: +3
Elton John
as The Butterfly in The Last Unicorn
Score: +2
Cate Blanchett
as Molly Grue in The Last Unicorn
Score: 0
Amanda Seyfried
as Lady Amalthea in The Last Unicorn
Score: 0
Jennifer Connelly
as Lady Connoire in The Squire's Tales
Score: +2
Jaime Murray
as Lady Connoire in The Squire's Tales
Score: +1
Alicia Silverstone
as Lady Connoire in The Squire's Tales
Score: +1
Dave Franco
as Gareth in The Squire's Tales
Score: 0
Gerard Butler
as Sir Kai in The Squire's Tales
Score: +1
Alden Ehrenreich
as Mordred in The Squire's Tales
Score: +1