Suggestions by @elijahspates

Brad Dourif

as Winners in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Robert Englund

as Winners in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Kane Hodder

as Winners in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Spoiler

as Winners in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Thom Mathews

as Tommy Jarvis in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Tyler Mane

as Rob zombie micheal myers in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

as Candyman 2021 in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Mark Hamill

as Chucky (Buddi) in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Linden Porco

as 2018 Leprechaun in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Jackie Earle Haley

as Reboot Freddy krueger in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Derek Mears

as Reboot jason voorhees in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Ken Kirzinger

as New Line Jason Voorhees in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Tony Todd

as Candyman in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Jack Quaid

as GhostFace in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Warwick Davis

as Leprechaun in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Dan Yeager

as Leatherface in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Brad Dourif

as Chucky in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Chris Evans

as Cordell Walker in Walker, Texas Ranger

James Jude Courtney

as Micheal Myers in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both

Robert Englund

as Freddy Krueger in Horrorverse: originals vs New versions or reboot versions or both